The Edinburgh Inquirer

The Edinburgh Inquirer

The Filth of Forth: We’re home to all of Scotland’s most polluted bathing beaches

Plus: Green walkway for old Powderhall railway “could be blown out of the water by £15m cost”

Edinburgh Inquirer's avatar
Edinburgh Inquirer
Nov 19, 2026
∙ Paid

Welcome to your midweek edition of The Inquirer.

The results of the latest bathing water quality test results make for unpleasant reading for anyone living around the Firth of Forth.

The impact of sewage dumping on our waterways has been a consistent theme of our reporting pretty much from day one (‘There are wet wipes and sanitary products hanging like prayer flags all along the river’) and the subject never fails to spark debate.

We also have an update on the long-running campaign to turn the former Powderhall railway line into a green corridor for walking and cycling.

That’s not good news either, we’re sorry to say. As Jolene Campbell’s report reveals, the estimated cost of the project has shot up, while campaigners are angry that it has become bogged down in fresh delays after years of talks.

Not all is doom and gloom, though. Will is here as usual with tonnes of great tips for exciting cultural adventures. We promise to bring you something cheerful in our weekend edition too.

The beach at Portobello where the water quality has been downgraded to poor. Pic: Callum Deas/Unsplash aption...

Your Edinburgh Briefing

THE FILTH OF FORTH: Four Scottish beaches have failed to make the basic standard for bathing water this year. All four of them are on the Firth of Forth. Portobello (West), Kinghorn and Lower Largo, in Fife, and Dunbar (East) on the mouth of the estuary in East Lothian. That means people are now advised against swimming at the four beaches. Poor water quality is usually linked to higher levels of bacteria, such as E coli and intestinal enterococci, which carry a health risk for swimmers.

Long-term problems: The results are particularly concerning because they are calculated to show long-term issues rather than rely on individual water sampling which can vary due to the weather and other factors. SEPA’s annual bathing water classifications are based on monitoring over four years.

‘Poor’ Porty water: Portobello (West), the area of the beach stretching from the Figgate Burn towards Seafield, has been downgraded to poor after being rated "sufficient" over the last nine years. Swimmers were advised to stay out of the water in the summer after tests found E coli levels at ten times the safe limit.

Dunbar blues: It is the first time that Dunbar (East) has also been rated poor, with gull fouling, sand loss and seaweed accumulation among a number of factors identified for causing the fall in water quality.

10-year leak: At Kinghorn, beside the Fife Coastal Path, one of the causes of E. coli in the water is thought to be a sewage leak, first reported in 2016, but whose source has yet to be identified by Scottish Water.

Scottish Water pointed to a £1m study it is carrying out to identify pollution sources across the wider Portobello area, adding: “At Portobello (West), lower water quality is closely linked to heavy rainfall and evidence suggests there are contributions from multiple sources, not all linked to Scottish Water’s sewers.”

What the SEPA report says: “Given the popularity of the Portobello bathing waters, work to protect and improve water quality was already underway before this change in classification occurred. At Portobello (West), investigations have indicated sewage, gulls and dogs as pollution sources.

“Scottish Water is carrying out a detailed pollution investigation across the catchment to identify and address pollution from sources such as sewer blockages and property misconnections. Any pollution issues identified through this investigation will be addressed as quickly as possible. Scottish Water is also undertaking a comprehensive hydraulic and water quality modelling study across the wider Portobello catchment. This £1 million study, due to conclude in early 2027, will identify potential infrastructure improvement projects for consideration within future investment programmes.

“SEPA are reviewing dry-weather spill performance and continuing to ensure that licensed infrastructure operates in compliance with environmental requirements and engaging with NatureScot and other partners on wider strategic approaches to managing gull-related impacts. The City of Edinburgh Council is continuing work to reduce the impacts of dog fouling, littering and the feeding of gulls, all of which can contribute to bacterial contamination reaching the bathing water.”

GRAND THEFT ‘EARTHQUAKE’: Described by The Washington Post as “a cultural and economic earthquake”, Edinburgh games maker Rockstar North launched its Grand Theft Auto 6 yesterday. Billed as the most expensive video game in history, its predecessor, Grand Theft Auto 5, was an entertainment industry record-breaker, making $1bn (£760m) in just three days. The latest release has received almost universally positive reviews from critics. Meanwhile, at an employment tribunal hearing in Glasgow, Rockstar has been accused of employing “shock and awe” tactics to punish trade union activity by sacking 34 staff.

FIRST DICHT: The popularity of the Craigmillar & Niddrie Litter Busters’ New Year’s Day Clean-up in 2026 has inspired a city-wide litter pick this New Year. The First Dicht - named after the old Scots word for cleaning - will invite city residents and visitors to spend an hour or so picking litter on 1 January. Supporters include Keep Scotland Beautiful, the City of Edinburgh Council, Paws on Plastic, Edinburgh & Lothians Greenspace Trust and the organisers of Edinburgh’s Winter Festivals. Full details will be published nearer the day.

HIGHNOTE: The former Royal High School which is being converted into the National Centre for Music on Regent Road has a new name. It will be known as Highnote following a rebranding by city-based creative agency StudioLR.

MORE TROUBLE AT HES: Another three senior managers have been suspended at the troubled heritage agency Historic Environment Scotland (HES), which oversees Edinburgh Castle and other significant historic buildings. The Scotsman reports that David Mitchell, director of cultural assets; Colin Tennant, head of technical conservation; and project manager Graham Briggs, have all stepped back from the organisation “with immediate effect”. The moves comes after former Dundee City Council chief executive David Martin was appointed to carry out a review of the working culture at HES following a string of scandals.

PLAYS, A PINT AND SAUSAGE ROLL: Fancy two great new plays, while munching through a delicious sausage roll and gulping down a pint? Then head to Leith Dockers Club on Monday, 23 November, at 12.30pm. One Night Only by Susan Chaney and The Runner by Jim Brown both feature the comic talents of TV’s Lynne McCallum, Isa’s pal in TV’s Still Game, alongside Citadel Arts regulars, Ashley Barlow, James Bryce, Chelsea Grace and Conrad Williamson. Tickets cost £10 and are available through Citadel Arts on lizhare@blueyonder.co.uk.

COMEDIAN PROTESTS INNOCENCE: Comedian Susan Riddell is among three women who have denied causing “malicious damage” to the Leonardo factory in Crewe Road North by driving a van into its perimeter fence. The trio are also accused of spraying paint and cutting the perimeter fence with a power tool. The 43-year-old comic also denied a charge of dangerous driving during an appearance at Edinburgh Sheriff Court.

Your Pick of the (Cultural) Pops

Greetings, Pop Pickers!

With East Princes Street Gardens now surrendered to the annual invasion of wooden chalets, the unmistakable scent of outrageously priced mulled wine thick in the freezing air, and the city bracing itself for the festive tourist crush, late November has arrived in the capital. While the Christmas markets are busy doing what they do best (a personal tip: seek out the mysterious Vegan Churros stall for the best and tastiest treats in the entire market), Edinburgh’s stages are refusing to let the cultural temperature drop, writes Will Quinn.

The incoming slate offers everything from arena-sized acoustic spectacles and high-camp local satire to the return of bona fide Fringe stars. As always, the competition for the top spots is utterly ferocious, resulting in a major reshuffle at the summit. Yes, indeed!

Right then, pop pickers - let’s count them down!

Honourable Mentions: Antarctic Pigments, Acoustic Ambition, and Brilliant Holdovers

Before we hit the Top 5, we must pay tribute to a genuinely stacked bubbler list. And let me tell you, even with an honourable mentions section this expansive, my metaphorical cutting room floor is littered with worthy contenders.

In the visual arts, (Dame) Barbara Rae: Charting South has opened at the Royal Scottish Academy (Ongoing). The globally acclaimed Scottish painter chronicles her expeditions to the freezing ends of the earth, showcasing intensely vibrant, semi-abstract landscapes that capture the Southern Ocean.

Musically, the Usher Hall is hosting a pair of spectacular gigs. First up, acclaimed acoustic singer-songwriter Fink pairs his atmospheric, blues-infused indie-folk with the newest local orchestra, Capella Edina (tonight). Having previously interviewed their founder, the brilliant young German conductor Luis Schmidt, for The Inquirer, I can attest to the ambition of this outfit; expect a deeply textured, spine-tingling wall of sound. Then, Scottish indie-folk outfit and Hoolie in the Hydro favourites Beluga Lagoon (Sunday) brings their nature-inspired soundscapes to the city’s grandest concert hall—sweeping, atmospheric folk that makes you want to buy a campervan and abandon city life for the Highlands.

And let’s not forget our brilliant holdovers still refusing to budge: Scotland Loves Anime closes out its week of massive European premieres and cult restorations across the Filmhouse and The Cameo (closes Sunday) - do not let the run finish without experiencing the kinetic 4K restoration of Ninja Scroll on the big screen! Meanwhile, the Edinburgh Short Film Festival continues its perfect cinematic tasting menu across the Filmhouse and Summerhall (closes Saturday). For live gigs and comedy, you still have time to catch glitchy Gen-Z noise-pop from Pittsburgh’s feeble little horse at La Belle Angèle (Saturday) and the effortless veteran polish of Ian Stone: Looking for the Wow at The Stand (Saturday).

New in at Number 5 is... Kim Blythe: Puzzle (Monkey Barrel Comedy, Nov 25th)

Breaking into the Top 5 is a masterclass in rising Scottish comedy talent. Missing Blythe numbered amongst my regrets this past Fringe, but there is no mistaking the buzz radiating from this rising star. Blythe is helping to lead a vanguard of new Scottish comedic voices destined for the very biggest stages. She brings her tightly written, Spirit of Glasgow Award-nominated confessional hour back to the city for an intimate room. While Bill Bailey headlines the cavernous Playhouse this week, the next big thing is quietly preparing to tear the roof off the Monkey Barrel. Book a ticket so you can smugly claim you saw her before the inevitable arena tours.

Staying at Number 4 is... Jamie Duffy (Pleasance Theatre, tonight)

Holding fast in the fourth spot as his Edinburgh date finally arrives, this 22-year-old Irish pianist and composer is a genuine digital phenomenon making his mark in the real world. His track “Solas” became a massive streaming juggernaut, making him the most-streamed debut artist in Ireland by effortlessly blending traditional Celtic folk warmth with his cinematic, neo-classical sound. Catching him in a 300-capacity room like The Pleasance tonight is a golden opportunity to see a rising star before he inevitably scales up to the Usher Hall on his next visit.

New in at Number 3 is... A Man for All Seasons (Festival Theatre, Nov 24th – 28th)

Taking the bronze medal is a major touring revival of Robert Bolt’s award-winning historical drama, bringing the most powerful and dangerous figures of English history vividly to life. The legendary Martin Shaw (known to millions for Judge John Deed, Inspector George Gently, and The Professionals) stars as Sir Thomas More - scholar, ambassador, Lord Chancellor, and loyal friend to King Henry VIII. When Henry demands a divorce from Catherine of Aragon to clear the way for Anne Boleyn, the staunchly Catholic man of integrity is forced to choose between royal loyalty and his own conscience, committing an incredible act of defiance for which he ultimately pays the price. Directed by Jonathan Church (who helmed Chichester Festival Theatre for a decade and recently directed Shaw in a West End Hobson’s Choice transfer), this is bona fide prestige theatre. Heavyweight, uncompromising, and the perfect antidote for those who find the encroaching festive season a bit too frivolous.

Dethroned from Number 1 to Number 2 is... Scottish Opera: Turandot (Festival Theatre, closes Sunday)

Surrendering the top spot not only because its phenomenal run is drawing to a close, but because an irresistible seasonal juggernaut is returning home to take second place. Sir David McVicar wrestles this flawed libretto into submission with an eccentric, visually opulent framing that lands somewhere between an Art Deco horror flick and Francis Ford Coppola’s Dracula. As The QR noted in a 4-star review, the macabre decay is delivered with breathtaking polish, propelled by Trine Møller’s fearsome, ringing intensity in the title role and Victor Starsky handling Nessun dorma with secure, unbuckling confidence. This is your final warning: catch this brilliant gothic nightmare before they dismantle the sets and ship them out of the capital this weekend.

New in at Number 1 is... King’s Panto: The Adventures of Pinocchio (King’s Theatre, Opens Nov 28th)

Rocketing straight to the top of the pops is the undisputed heavyweight champion of Edinburgh’s festive theatrical season, making a glorious, long-awaited homecoming! The legendary pantomime officially launches the capital’s Christmas calendar as it throws open the doors of the newly reopened King’s Theatre. With Allan Stewart, Grant Stott, and Jordan Young still leading the cast, this beloved institution continues to defy the UK-wide trend of reality TV casting. Instead, expect our star trio to deliver deeply Scottish, delightfully chaotic, and relentless local satire. Loud, aggressively colourful, and packed with in-jokes that will leave visiting tourists bewildered, it remains an essential Edinburgh tradition. Surrender your intellectual high ground for the evening, embrace the festive chaos, and secure your tickets before they vanish!

And that’s your Top 5!

Whether you are seeking refuge from the Christmas markets in the high-stakes Tudor politics of the Festival Theatre, plunging into the neon-lit world of 90s anime, or letting Jamie Duffy’s neo-classical soundscapes wash over you, there is no excuse to stay indoors this week. And as always, the brilliant review team at TheQR.co.uk will be out in force, providing their expert verdicts on the biggest openings.

I shall leave you to it while I go and enjoy a batch of fresh churros. What’s taking the top spot on your own cultural dance card this week? Let me know in the comments—right after you’ve hit those booking links!

Until next week: Stay bright!


We need your support to produce the Edinburgh Inquirer. Only our paying members make all our high-quality journalism possible. Joining costs just £1.54 a week when you sign up for a full year. It is the only way to access all our writing, and your money goes directly to paying our professional journalists and supporting their work.


Green walkway for old Powderhall railway “could be blown out of the water by £15m cost”

Anger as long-awaited plan for new green corridor faces further delay and uncertainty

by Jolene Campbell

The conversion of part of an old Edinburgh railway line into a new green corridor for pedestrians and cyclists could be derailed over a lack of funding and “embarrassing” delays.

The city council has been in talks for several years with Network Rail about taking over the redundant Powderhall line between Powderhall and Meadowbank, but no agreement has been reached.

Now fresh doubt has been cast over the project after updated estimates put the cost at at least £10-15 million and the city’s transport convener Cllr Stephen Jenkison warned "there is no money to do it".

Cllr Jenkinson told The Inquirer the estimated costs could "blow it out of the water". The Scottish Government’s annual active travel budget is around £15m, and the railway line is one of more than 40 other applications to the fund.

Jenkinson warned that the active travel budget won't be able to foot the bill and has called on the Scottish Government - which pledged its support to the project during the last Scottish Parliament election- to stump up cash.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of David Forsyth.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Edinburgh Inquirer · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.